*image credit flicker birgirking
Writers are either hideously rich and famous or drug-addicted narcissists. If you think it, it must be true.
Right?
George Orwell said all writers are vain, selfish, and lazy (read the full essay Why I Write). And if George Orwell says it, it must be true.
Right?
T.C. Boyle said in the Huffington Post that all writers are egomaniacal, manic depressive, drug-addicted alcoholics. And if a best-selling author says it and the HuffPo publishes it, it must be true.
Right?
Are you vain, selfish, and lazy? Hideously rich and famous? A drug-addicted narcissist? A manic-depressive alcoholic with an ego the size of Miley Cyrus’s tongue?
Or…
Do you take pictures of yourself at the beach with The Writer magazine?
Do you write? On paper or keyboard or typewriter? Sentences scribbled on scraps of snotty Kleenex found in the bottom of your purse? Dirty napkins? Post-Its? Your daughter’s homework pages? Do you form sentences and create narrative arcs and craft paragraphs and intend to show it to someone (mom, blog followers, literary agent)?
But I’m not a real writer until someone pays me, you say? Hey – I didn’t earn any money for the gazillions of dirty diapers I changed while my twins were young and I guarantee you, I was a real dirty-diaper-changer. No one pays me for the miles I log running around Djibouti but I guarantee you (and the stench of my sweat-soaked clothes and the muscles in my calves prove) that I am a real runner.
But I’m not a real writer until someone other than my mom and five blog followers read it, you say? First off – you wrote something down, didn’t you? Something a bit more involved than a shopping list or 140-character tweet? Then you’re a writer. Second – if no one has read it, whose fault is that? Did you show it to anyone? Did you ask anyone to read it? More about how to do this in a future post. Third, every writer has to start somewhere, has to start with zero. So you have zero readers? Write anyway. Next week you might have two.
According to Webster’s Dictionary, a writer is a person who writes. Technically, yes of course. But on the deeper level of identification I would like to push on this. My husband writes emails and letters to the Djiboutian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. He writes on immigration forms and Happy Birthday cards. He even writes long, involved, technical papers for his PhD studies. But he doesn’t want to be a writer. He wants to be Dr. Jones, university professor. He doesn’t identify as a writer.
So on a personal level, if you write and you want to consider yourself a writer, feel free. Claim it. In this sense, being a writer means more than putting words to paper. It means a way of interacting with the world, it means the work that you do and the gifts that you bring. It means the ache welling up in your chest and the passion with which you pour yourself into those words.
My husband writes those documents as a means to an end. A visa, an immigration stamp, to convey birthday wishes, to receive a PhD. He is told to fulfill these obligations and complies. A writer writes from an inner compulsion. Even a writer procrastinating on a deadline stares at the blank screen or downs the glass of wine with the knowledge that the work ahead will cut to the marrow, and still wants to do it. A writer pours heart and conviction and meaning and self into the words.
When do you think someone can call themselves a writer? How many Djibouti Jones readers are writers? Come on, ‘fess up. Claim it.
I have loved to write since grade school. After a long season of drought, I started writing again and my blog is the platform I share my writings with but I still can’t say I am a writer. I am a missionary who loves to write. Loved this post. So encouraging!
Well when you’re ready…claim it! Until then, keep writing.
All right…I’ll fess up. I’m a writer. I’ve never been paid to do it, but I do enjoy it…when I can make the time to do it. It’s cathartic for me. I have a hard time putting thoughts, stories, and opinions into spoken words, but when I can take the time to write…then I can much more adequately say what I want to say. It’s hard, though, and takes time. I’m very careful with my words and think a lot about what I want to write before I write it. But I enjoy it. Maybe someday I’ll work on honing my writing skills more. (At this time, having 4 growing kids at home, plus a 7-month-old that I babysit 45+ hours a week, just has me in a different season of life.) For now, I enjoy writing when I can…and I enjoy reading much more gifted writers’ stories, books, and articles…yours in particular! 🙂
Ooo, I so love learning this about you Mandy. Yeah, seasons of life are a big thing when it comes to writing.
I am a writer. Not because I’m good- but because I write to stay sane. 🙂
Love this – so true. That’s exactly how I describe it sometimes. To stay sane. Helps me process, think, see things differently…Just imagine the world if all of us stay-sane-writers didn’t write?!
Ok, I’m a writer. Self-published a book 5 yrs ago but now wonder if that gift was for a season. Your post tells me the truth that I can’t wiggle away from. I still love words. Which is a good thing, now that I’m teaching English in Poland. I wandered upon your blog and stayed because I’m a 3rd culture kid and love hearing others’ stories that you share so well here. Thanks!
Loving words – so central to writing. I know what you mean, even words in a foreign language, I love hearing them and figuring out their complex meanings. Congrats on publishing your book, that’s a huge accomplishment!
ditto to georgia’s comment above.
Aren’t we all vain, selfish, and lazy? (I know I am) It’s the human condition.
I discovered I enjoyed writing when I started blogging, which was a shock since they say scientists are terrible writers (I am a geologist, too, go figure). Writing on the mission field was one of the only ways to process all we were going through – it kept me from losing my mind. Now it’s just a fun outlet for creativity and communication. And yes, some of us may not write like Charlotte Bronte, but I sure enjoy reading what others write! I imagine Heaven as one, big beautiful library! lol
I totally just said to a friend today that heaven will have the most amazing library. That must be a common writerly dream, or readerly dream.
I’m a writer too. Just started saying that out loud about a year ago.
I have a completely opposite situation. I have consciously written something only couple of times in my life, but I feel like a writer inside, somehow always have. Maybe if I get lucky (and less lazy) enough, “outside” will catch up on this one day, too 🙂
Well, here’s hoping you turn inside out someday! Figuratively speaking.
[…] weeks ago we talked about how to know if you are a writer or not and when you can claim the word as your own. What about when you think it is time to move on […]
How did I miss this article? Love this. This is a huge thing for me. I so want to claim this but feel that angst that I am an impostor. And yes – I do the napkin, business card, paper towel writing thing – to make sure I capture an idea.
Hate to break it to you Marilyn, but you are no impostor.
Not all writers are drug-addicts but most drug-addicts ARE vain, selfish, and ego-maniacal. If you are focusing on writers who happen to be drug-addicts, you are therefore bound to see them as such.
Hi Rachel,
I’ve been reading your blog for the past two years. It inspires me. I keep reading and re-reading some of your older articles.
Very recently, I’ve started blogging as a hobby. Yes, I get ideas while traveling in the bus. So , I keep a notepad handy. Or just type some words on my cellphone. So, maybe I am a writer(?)